214

RATE

How large does a crocodile/alligator have to be before it is large enough to be considered a dinosaur?

comment kid: It sure looks like one, with all those big sharp teeth, thick armoured points covering its back, and those long claws.

comment kid's Avatar

2 years ago

Answers

Size, while being a partial factor to determining what is and is not a dinosaur, is not enough for a simple classification of a crocodile or alligator to be deemed a dinosaur.

There are many types of ways in which something gets classified in taxonomy. To keep from going into all the details about what makes up Phylum Cordata and Class Reptilia and Infraclass Archosauromorpha, then the differences that occurs between the Superorder Dinosauria and Superorder Crocodylomorpha, let us recognize that taxonomy is a boring subject to me and I intend to skirt over the specific details.

The fact of the matter is that what is called a dinosaur cannot be what is seen as today's crocodiles and alligators, as well as other currently existing relatives (i.e. caiman and gharial). Their distant prehistoric relatives may have been known as terrible lizards, but modern day creatures are nothing more than watered down shams of their ancestors.

Wow now here is a find!
From ucmp.berkley.edu/diapsids/archosauria.html


The ancestral archosaurs probably originated some 250 million years or so ago, in the late Permian period. Their descendants (such as the dinosaurs) dominated the realm of the terrestrial vertebrates for a majority of the Mesozoic Era. Today, only the birds and crocodilians exist to provide a glimpse into the past glory of archosaurs.

Chicken Nugget's Avatar

Comments should be reserved for the comment feature... Furthermore, saying that avids and crocodylomorphas are related to archosauromorphas only reiterates what I already said. The sole contribution of saying birds are related to dinosaurs is something I neglected because I figured a question about crocodiles/alligators really had no purpose to mention that fact.

comment kid's Avatar

The Berkley website is saying crocs are dinos. They aren't related they are dinosaurs.

felixthecat's Avatar

Crocodiles are not dinosaurs. They share a common ancestor, the archosaurs. Go back a bit farther, and humans and dinosaurs share a common ancestor with fish. Does that make us all fish?

  • god
  • -  4827 pts
  • -  (2 years ago)

crocodiles and alligators are not dinosaurs....
Never will be, never were.

 

What is Questional?

We interview experts, scientists, and public figures in tech & science as well as community Q & A!

Asking questions and getting answers is what we do.

Subscribe via RSS Subscribe via Email

Recent Literature

Smartphones for the 2011 Holiday Season

With Christmas coming up, Questional.com compares a few of the newest smartphones - the Samsung Galaxy Nexus, the iPhone 4S, and Motorola Droid 4. Which one do you want to...

Jean-Michel Claverie

Jean-Michel Claverie, French scientist extraordinaire, was kind enough to give Questional this interview. Claverie, one of the discoverers of megavirus chilensis, is a pio...

More Tech Toys for the 2011 Holiday Season

Still looking for that unique gift? Questional covers more tech toys for the holiday season. Everything from cuddly pathogens to flying machines, electronic bugs and mind gam...

Tech Toys for the 2011 Holiday Season

Don't buy another iTunes gift card for that office buddy - get a little creative this year. There are some very cool albeit a little quirky tech toys for that hard...

Dear Santa - A Few Holiday 2011 Gadgets I'd Enjoy

Dear Santa,
This year's holiday season is sure to be full of fun gadgets and toys for the tech-savvy, so I thought I'd review a few of my personal favorites...

Request For Interview

Questional is always on the lookout for great interviewees.

If you're a professional, an expert, or feel like your interview would be a great read to our guests + members we want to hear from you! - Contact Us